Commentary Driving: Enhancing Forward Planning and Insight for Driving Instructors

Commentary driving is a powerful tool for developing driving instructors and learners alike. By verbalizing their observations, decisions, and reasoning as they drive, instructors can sharpen their planning, gain awareness of potential hazards, and reinforce good driving habits. For trainers working with new instructors, commentary driving is invaluable—it offers a glimpse into the instructor’s mindset, helping trainers assess their trainees' situational awareness, decision-making, and risk-management skills.

This article explores the benefits of commentary driving, detailing how it strengthens planning and offers trainers a unique insight into the trainee's thought processes.

What is Commentary Driving?

Commentary driving involves narrating one’s thoughts aloud while driving. This commentary may include observations about the road, anticipated hazards, plans for positioning, speed adjustments, and any other factors affecting safe driving. When ADIs (Approved Driving Instructors) use commentary driving as both a self-assessment tool and a teaching technique, helping instructors refine their skills and model effective habits for learners.

Benefits of Commentary Driving for Forward Planning

One key advantage of commentary driving is that it enhances forward planning—an essential skill for safe and confident driving. Through commentary, instructors verbalize their observations and intended actions, making them more aware of the road ahead and how to respond to potential risks. This active engagement with the environment improves anticipation, reaction times, and overall control, fostering a proactive rather than reactive approach to driving.

How Commentary Driving Strengthens Forward Planning

1. Improved Hazard Perception
Commentary driving encourages instructors to scan the road and continuously identify potential hazards. Verbalizing these hazards as they appear promotes an awareness of risks that might go unnoticed. For instance, an instructor might say, “I see a pedestrian near the edge of the pavement ahead—I’ll check my mirrors and prepare to slow down if they step onto the road.” This type of proactive thinking reduces the risk of sudden, reactive decisions.

2. Enhanced Awareness of Road Conditions and Changes
Road conditions can vary widely, requiring drivers to adjust their behavior accordingly. By commenting on road signs, surface conditions, and other cues, instructors train themselves to anticipate changes in driving requirements. For example, noting an upcoming change in speed limit helps them plan ahead and adjust gradually rather than making a last-minute change that could disrupt their control or flow.

3. Greater Focus on Positioning and Space
Commentary driving also encourages instructors to plan their positioning well in advance. Verbalizing decisions about lane choice, distance from other vehicles, and road positioning for turns reinforces their commitment to maintaining safe space and optimal positioning. For instance, stating, “I’ll stay to the left in case this vehicle in the right lane changes lanes suddenly,” demonstrates spatial awareness and thoughtful positioning.

4. Preparation for Complex Scenarios
When approaching complex driving scenarios—such as roundabouts, multi-lane junctions, or busy pedestrian areas—commentary driving enables instructors to mentally rehearse and plan their actions. By vocalizing these plans, they reinforce their understanding of the necessary steps and build confidence in handling these situations safely.

 Insight for Trainers: Getting Inside the Instructor’s Head

For trainers, commentary driving is a unique tool that provides direct insight into the trainee’s thought process. By listening to a trainee’s commentary, trainers can assess the depth of the instructor’s awareness, the quality of their decision-making, and their ability to anticipate and respond to potential hazards. This level of insight is invaluable, allowing trainers to tailor feedback and guidance to address specific areas of development.

How Commentary Driving Reveals a Trainee’s Thought Process

1. Assessment of Observational Skills
Commentary driving reveals the trainee’s attention to detail and observational skills. By listening to what the trainee chooses to mention—or omit—trainers gain a sense of their situational awareness. If a trainee consistently comments on pedestrians, cyclists, and other vehicles, it suggests strong awareness. However, if they overlook key elements like blind spots or emerging vehicles, it may indicate areas that need improvement.

2. Insight into Hazard Perception and Risk Management
A trainee’s commentary provides clues about their hazard perception abilities. Trainers can gauge whether the trainee is merely reacting to hazards or actively identifying them before they become an issue. For instance, a trainee who comments on an upcoming crosswalk and notes the potential for pedestrian crossings demonstrates proactive hazard perception. Conversely, a lack of commentary on these potential risks may suggest a need for further training in identifying hazards.

3. Understanding of Decision-Making and Planning
Commentary driving allows trainers to understand how trainees make speed, positioning, and lane choice decisions. A well-structured commentary shows that the trainee plans rather than making split-second decisions. For example, if the trainee comments, “I’ll stay back from this cyclist until it’s safe to pass,” it indicates good planning and risk management. Trainers can then provide feedback on areas where the trainee’s decision-making could be more assertive or better aligned with safe practices.

4. Identifying Confidence and Professionalism
The tone and clarity of the commentary can also reveal a trainee’s confidence and professionalism. Clear, decisive commentary suggests high confidence, whereas hesitancy or uncertainty may signal areas where the trainee feels less secure. Trainers can use this insight to offer targeted support, such as additional practice on challenging manoeuvres or further guidance on complex road scenarios.

Examples of Effective Commentary Driving

Here are some examples of practical commentary that demonstrate strong planning and awareness:

1. Approaching a Junction
"I see the junction ahead, so I’ll start checking my mirrors and reducing my speed. I’ll position myself to the left to ensure good visibility of oncoming traffic. Once I reach the stop line, I’ll check for a clear gap before proceeding.”*

This commentary shows awareness of the junction, a clear positioning and speed control plan, and anticipation of the steps needed to approach safely.

2. Navigating a Busy Pedestrian Area
“A pedestrian is crossing ahead, and I can see a group of people on the left side. I’ll slow down and prepare to stop if they step onto the crossing. I’ll keep checking my mirrors to ensure there’s no one close behind.”

This example demonstrates the trainee’s ability to identify potential risks and prepare to respond while remaining aware of the traffic behind them.

3. Changing Lanes on a Dual Carriageway
“I need to move into the right lane, so I’ll check my mirrors and signal. I see a vehicle approaching quickly in the right lane, so I’ll wait until they pass before moving over.”

Here, the commentary reflects an understanding of both positioning and the importance of timing, with the trainee showing good judgment in waiting for a clear opportunity.

Developing Effective Commentary Driving Skills

For trainees and trainers, practical commentary driving is a skill that can be developed with practice. Here are a few tips to strengthen commentary skills:

Practice in a Variety of Environments: Encourage trainees to practice commentary in diverse settings, from city streets to rural roads. This broadens their experience and enhances their ability to plan in different conditions.
Focus on Specific Elements: If a trainee struggles with a particular area, such as hazard perception or positioning, focus their commentary on these elements until they become more confident.
Encourage Reflection: After a session, discuss the trainee’s commentary, highlighting areas of strength and identifying opportunities for improvement. This reflection reinforces good habits and promotes growth.

Conclusion: The Value of Commentary Driving

Commentary driving is more than a teaching technique—it’s a comprehensive approach to building planning, enhancing situational awareness, and understanding a trainee’s thought processes. For trainers, it’s an invaluable way to get inside the instructor’s head, identifying strengths and areas for improvement that might otherwise go unnoticed.

By integrating commentary driving into their training, instructors and trainees alike can develop a proactive, thoughtful approach to driving, ultimately leading to safer, more confident driving behaviour on the road.

Contact Chris Today!